NavigationWho's new
|
Can self-proclaimed "pro-lifers" really be feminists?![]() words by media girl posted July 29, 2005 - 5:37pm
ferdette asks this on mediagirl.org:
What are your thoughts? Is an issue of Economic Pragmatism, not morality. The Webmaster at Raving Atheist also considers himself a feminist and is also Pro-life. The thing is there is a difference between your defining her morals and her wanting to legalize hers. I guess I would want to know what your friend thought the punishment should be for Abortion. Maybe we should invite them to a debate. :-) (1)
How can you be pro-women's-rights in all of these other areas, but when it comes to a woman's fundamental right to control her body, determine her reproductive destiny, her reproductive freedom, her autonomy, and her right to tell and demonstrate to a patriarchal society that she will not be made into birthing chattel against her will, you're against it--so how can you honestly be feminist? And how can you be feminist when you go by the "moral values" according to patriarchal standards when it comes to pregnancy and women's bodies? To me it is an oxymoron and personally, I do not believe that you can be feminist, yet be against a woman's right to choose. To me, reproductive rights--abortion and contraception--are too fundamental in promoting women's liberation from patriarchal societal constructs. (0)
One of the Commenters put up this from Findlaw
(1)
![]() i've met some women over the years who claimed to be "pro life" feminists. their argument was that patriarchy does not value the sanctity of lives other than their own. feminism in contrast, should be about affirming life. now, i could at least follow that logic from those who, although personally pro-life, believed that the law should protect each woman's right to choose. but the ones who thought abortion should be made illegal, that women should be forced into the role of fetus nurturer against her will? that never made any sense to me at all. i respect feminists who personally would choose not to have an abortion. i can't respect the stance of those who would legislate their personal choice onto other women. those women may choose to call themselves feminists, but they aren't. (1)
![]() I never heard of FFL until I tangled with a few of them who attacked me for the evils of supporting PP (I'd posted about a program PP has in SW Virginia in which they're bundled with an adoption agency for easy referrals to women who want more detailed information about adoption). The comments I consistently receive from those who claim to be/support FFL is that a "real feminist" understands that abortion is the rejection of motherhood (the word infanticide was used a lot) and a woman's repsonsibility in the face of pregnancy. Somehow in deciding not to go to term with a pregnancy, women who have abortions are capitulating to the patriarchal view that diminshes the role of motherhood and therefor of women. It's an argument that makes no sense to me at all except in the case of a woman who terminates against her wishes at the command of the father. -------------------------------------- (0)
This group was named by the same people who created the title for Bush's "Clean Air Initiative." Inspite of the group however it is an interesting question and worth going over as each of us comes to her own idea of what Feminism is. (1)
![]() Paraphrasing: Abortion makes it possible for teens to hide the fact that they've been molested. If they carry to term, then it becomes clear that they're pregnant and then people will know. So not only is pregnancy punishment for women having sex, it's also bait to trap molesters. (Oh yeah, and any minor who has sex has been molested.) (oh oh, I almost forgot, if girls didn't have birth control, then they would not have sex. *smacks head* Wow! How easy the world's problems can be solved. We all just need to be Pollyannas!) (1)
![]() when they're hit with a lawsuit to pay child support? --------------------------- (0)
» "Can self-proclaimed "pro-lifers" really be feminists?"
|
Recent comments
1 year 17 weeks ago
1 year 17 weeks ago
1 year 17 weeks ago
1 year 17 weeks ago
1 year 17 weeks ago
1 year 28 weeks ago
1 year 42 weeks ago
1 year 46 weeks ago
2 years 5 weeks ago
2 years 9 weeks ago